NFL Draft: Best Picks and Biggest Busts
Rob Moore
More like this on TwitterTwitter
Methodology
- A player's rating is derived from their career Approximate Value (AV) as per Pro Football Reference, along with their annual PFF scores. The rating system gives slight preference to the initial years of a player's career, as these years typically yield higher value for the drafting team.
- A player's ROI is calculated as the difference between the player's actual rating and the expected rating, which is based on their draft position.
- The best picks are identified by the highest player rating, while the biggest busts are those with the most negative player ROI.
Player Rating
Hall of Fame
90+
All Pro
80+
Elite
70+
Great
60+
Pick's Expected Value
Round 1
26 - 41
Rounds 2 & 3
13 - 26
Rounds 4 - 7
4 - 13
NFL Draft (2006 - 2023)
NFL Draft (2006 - 2023) Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/13Aaron Donald129
1/2Von Miller113
1/11J.J. Watt111
1/3Matt Ryan110
1/11Patrick Willis108
1/10Patrick Mahomes108
1/5Khalil Mack108
1/6Julio Jones101
1/16Zack Martin101
1/9Luke Kuechly100
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/75Russell Wilson112
2/37Chris Jones98
2/42Rob Gronkowski98
2/47Bobby Wagner97
2/55Andrew Whitworth96
3/86Marshal Yanda96
3/63Travis Kelce92
2/47Michael Thomas89
2/51A.J. Brown88
2/37Eric Weddle84
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/195Antonio Brown103
4/108Jahri Evans101
5/154Richard Sherman100
4/120Geno Atkins95
5/165Tyreek Hill94
4/135Josh Sitton90
6/191Jason Kelce88
5/146Stefon Diggs85
4/135Dak Prescott84
5/146George Kittle84
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/1JaMarcus Russell-42
1/3Solomon Thomas-41
1/3Jeff Okudah-41
1/5Devin White-40
1/4Aaron Curry-39
1/6Vernon Gholston-39
1/8Justin Gilbert-38
1/9Ernie Sims-38
1/7Kevin White-38
1/2Zach Wilson-38
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/33Kevin Dodd-27
2/32Phillip Merling-27
2/37Greg Little-26
2/35Brian Price-26
2/35Malik McDowell-26
2/35Mario Edwards-26
2/40John Beck-26
2/37Alphonso Smith-25
2/40Ross Blacklock-25
2/40Daniel Bullocks-25
Team-by-team breakdown
Display By:
Arizona Cardinals
Arizona Cardinals Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/5Patrick Peterson2011
67
1/1Kyler Murray2019
59
1/16Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie2008
46
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/50Calais Campbell2008
80
3/69Tyrann Mathieu2013
66
2/47Daryl Washington2010
61
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/112Bobby Massie2012
39
5/142Steve Breaston2007
31
5/136Anthony Sherman2011
31
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/10Josh Rosen2018
-37
1/10Matt Leinart2006
-37
1/8Isaiah Simmons2020
-33
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/52Troy Niklas2014
-20
2/63Cody Brown2009
-19
2/38Ryan Williams2011
-19
Atlanta Falcons
Atlanta Falcons Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/3Matt Ryan2008
110
1/6Julio Jones2011
101
1/14Chris Lindstrom2019
72
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/52Deion Jones2016
44
2/39Justin Blalock2007
42
2/37Curtis Lofton2008
31
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/137Grady Jarrett2015
63
5/151Tyler Allgeier2022
60
5/147Ricardo Allen2014
41
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/8Jamaal Anderson2007
-32
1/24Peria Jerry2009
-30
1/8Vic Beasley2015
-22
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/40Richie Grant2021
-23
2/47Marlon Davidson2020
-20
2/55William Moore2009
-20
Baltimore Ravens
Baltimore Ravens Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/32Lamar Jackson2018
82
1/14Kyle Hamilton2022
71
1/12Haloti Ngata2006
71
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/86Marshal Yanda2007
96
3/86Mark Andrews2018
69
2/60Kelechi Osemele2012
58
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/180Tyrod Taylor2011
51
6/204Darren Waller2015
50
4/122Za'Darius Smith2015
50
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/32Matt Elam2013
-27
1/28Patrick Queen2020
-20
1/25Hayden Hurst2018
-19
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/42Kamalei Correa2016
-24
2/43Sergio Kindle2010
-23
2/57Terrence Cody2010
-20
Buffalo Bills
Buffalo Bills Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/7Josh Allen2018
91
1/12Marshawn Lynch2007
66
1/30Gregory Rousseau2021
60
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/63Dion Dawkins2017
64
2/51Andy Levitre2009
61
2/34Paul Posluszny2007
60
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/134Kyle Williams2006
61
5/166Wyatt Teller2018
50
7/224Stevie Johnson2008
49
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/16EJ Manuel2013
-34
1/11Aaron Maybin2009
-33
1/16Tremaine Edmunds2018
-18
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/41James Hardy2008
-25
2/38Cody Ford2019
-25
2/41Torell Troup2010
-25
Carolina Panthers
Carolina Panthers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/9Luke Kuechly2012
100
1/8Christian McCaffrey2017
83
1/1Cam Newton2011
81
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/44Kawann Short2013
74
2/59Ryan Kalil2007
66
2/64Taylor Moton2017
56
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/175Greg Hardy2010
48
5/143Josh Norman2012
44
4/102Daryl Williams2015
42
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/30Vernon Butler2016
-26
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/37Greg Little2019
-26
2/48Jimmy Clausen2010
-23
2/38Yetur Gross-Matos2020
-22
Chicago Bears
Chicago Bears Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/31Greg Olsen2007
57
1/20Kyle Long2013
49
1/9Leonard Floyd2016
41
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/45Alshon Jeffery2012
66
2/44Matt Forte2008
49
2/56Cody Whitehair2016
48
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/142Adrian Amos2015
54
7/246Charles Leno Jr.2014
53
4/112Eddie Jackson2017
40
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/7Kevin White2015
-38
1/19Shea McClellin2012
-31
1/14Chris Williams2008
-17
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/51Ego Ferguson2014
-21
2/62Dan Bazuin2007
-19
3/71Hroniss Grasu2015
-18
Cincinnati Bengals
Cincinnati Bengals Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/1Joe Burrow2020
86
1/4A.J. Green2011
83
1/27Kevin Zeitler2012
73
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/55Andrew Whitworth2006
96
2/54Carlos Dunlap2010
69
2/35Andy Dalton2011
61
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/120Geno Atkins2010
95
5/166Marvin Jones2012
54
4/101Clint Boling2011
45
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/9John Ross2017
-36
1/21Billy Price2018
-31
1/21Cedric Ogbuehi2015
-24
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/46Jackson Carman2021
-23
2/49Kenny Irons2007
-22
2/53Jake Fisher2015
-22
Cleveland Browns
Cleveland Browns Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/1Myles Garrett2017
100
1/3Joe Thomas2007
97
1/21Alex Mack2009
82
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/35Nick Chubb2018
76
2/35Joel Bitonio2014
71
2/37Mitchell Schwartz2012
70
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/140Brandon McDonald2007
32
4/126Isaiah McGuire2023
31
6/190Luke Wypler2023
28
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/8Justin Gilbert2014
-38
1/19Cameron Erving2015
-32
1/22Johnny Manziel2014
-31
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/36Brian Robiskie2009
-25
2/52DeShone Kizer2017
-22
2/59Montario Hardesty2010
-21
Dallas Cowboys
Dallas Cowboys Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/16Zack Martin2014
101
1/12Micah Parsons2021
94
1/9Tyron Smith2011
92
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/34DeMarcus Lawrence2014
78
2/55Sean Lee2010
61
3/71DeMarco Murray2011
54
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/135Dak Prescott2016
84
4/128Tony Pollard2019
59
4/122Doug Free2007
50
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/18Bobby Carpenter2006
-28
1/6Morris Claiborne2012
-27
1/28Taco Charlton2017
-21
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/44Kelvin Joseph2021
-22
2/40Bruce Carter2011
-22
2/58Trysten Hill2019
-21
Denver Broncos
Denver Broncos Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/2Von Miller2011
113
1/22Demaryius Thomas2010
81
1/12Ryan Clady2008
67
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/98Justin Simmons2016
58
3/98Quinn Meinerz2021
56
3/87Eric Decker2010
51
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/119Brandon Marshall2006
84
6/207Matt Paradis2014
55
5/137Malik Jackson2012
51
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/17Jarvis Moss2007
-30
1/25Tim Tebow2010
-30
1/26Paxton Lynch2016
-29
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/37Alphonso Smith2009
-25
2/46KJ Hamler2020
-22
2/56Tim Crowder2007
-21
Detroit Lions
Detroit Lions Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/2Calvin Johnson2007
86
1/1Matthew Stafford2009
83
1/7Penei Sewell2021
76
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/65Larry Warford2013
61
2/36Darius Slay2013
57
2/45Brian Branch2023
53
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/112Amon-Ra St. Brown2021
81
6/199Theo Riddick2013
39
6/200Quandre Diggs2015
33
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/3Jeff Okudah2020
-41
1/9Ernie Sims2006
-38
1/21Jarrad Davis2017
-31
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/40Daniel Bullocks2006
-25
2/43Drew Stanton2007
-24
2/45Jordon Dizon2008
-24
Green Bay Packers
Green Bay Packers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/26Clay Matthews2009
67
1/27Kenny Clark2016
65
1/18Jaire Alexander2018
57
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/53Davante Adams2014
74
2/36Jordy Nelson2008
70
2/62Casey Hayward2012
69
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/135Josh Sitton2008
90
4/109David Bakhtiari2013
79
5/182Aaron Jones2017
70
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/16Justin Harrell2007
-34
1/9B.J. Raji2009
-31
1/26Datone Jones2013
-29
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/33Kevin King2017
-23
2/51Jerel Worthy2012
-22
2/56Mike Neal2010
-20
Houston Texans
Houston Texans Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/11J.J. Watt2011
111
1/27DeAndre Hopkins2013
88
1/26Duane Brown2008
83
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/76Brandon Brooks2012
75
3/66Eric Winston2006
60
3/89Nico Collins2021
55
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/166D.J. Reader2016
57
4/99Ben Jones2012
55
4/98Owen Daniels2006
45
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/10Amobi Okoye2007
-36
1/16Kevin Johnson2015
-31
1/23Tytus Howard2019
-16
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/40Ross Blacklock2020
-25
2/50Nick Martin2016
-22
2/54Lonnie Johnson Jr.2019
-20
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/6Quenton Nelson2018
73
1/1Andrew Luck2012
71
1/22Anthony Castonzo2011
69
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/92T.Y. Hilton2012
75
2/36Shaquille Leonard2018
63
3/77Bernhard Raimann2022
57
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/207Antoine Bethea2006
54
6/205Pierre Garcon2008
49
6/199Charlie Johnson2006
40
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/24Bjoern Werner2013
-21
1/29Phillip Dorsett2015
-16
1/27Donald Brown2009
-9
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/49Ben Banogu2019
-23
2/57T.J. Green2016
-21
2/56Fili Moala2009
-21
Jacksonville Jaguars
Jacksonville Jaguars Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/5Jalen Ramsey2016
73
1/7Josh Allen2019
61
1/8Eugene Monroe2009
50
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/60Maurice Jones-Drew2006
58
3/93Brandon Linder2014
57
2/61Allen Robinson2014
55
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/142Brandon Marshall2012
42
5/144Telvin Smith2014
41
5/149Uche Nwaneri2007
37
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/10Blaine Gabbert2011
-37
1/9C.J. Henderson2020
-37
1/20K'Lavon Chaisson2020
-32
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/33Johnathan Cyprien2013
-25
3/76Will Rackley2011
-17
2/38Andre Branch2012
-17
Kansas City Chiefs
Kansas City Chiefs Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/10Patrick Mahomes2017
108
1/20Tamba Hali2006
64
1/23Dwayne Bowe2007
59
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/37Chris Jones2016
98
3/63Travis Kelce2013
92
3/70Justin Houston2011
83
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/165Tyreek Hill2016
94
6/226Trey Smith2021
45
7/251Isiah Pacheco2022
42
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/3Tyson Jackson2009
-33
1/26Jonathan Baldwin2011
-28
1/5Glenn Dorsey2008
-22
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/54Turk McBride2007
-21
2/46Breeland Speaks2018
-21
3/67Alex Magee2009
-19
Las Vegas Raiders
Las Vegas Raiders Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/5Khalil Mack2014
108
1/24Josh Jacobs2019
66
1/4Amari Cooper2015
64
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/36Derek Carr2014
70
3/69Jared Veldheer2010
54
3/81Gabe Jackson2014
47
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/106Maxx Crosby2019
68
7/235Shelby Harris2014
57
5/140Maurice Hurst Jr.2018
36
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/1JaMarcus Russell2007
-42
1/12D.J. Hayden2013
-35
1/17Alex Leatherwood2021
-33
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/35Mario Edwards2015
-26
2/44Jihad Ward2016
-24
2/42Menelik Watson2013
-22
Los Angeles Chargers
Los Angeles Chargers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/6Justin Herbert2020
81
1/3Joey Bosa2016
78
1/13Rashawn Slater2021
65
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/37Eric Weddle2007
84
3/76Keenan Allen2013
82
3/78Louis Vasquez2009
67
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/151Desmond King2017
43
4/110Ladarius Green2012
39
7/240Brandon Siler2007
35
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/16Larry English2009
-34
1/23Kenneth Murray2020
-30
1/28Jerry Tillery2019
-29
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/38Forrest Lamp2017
-24
2/49Kendall Reyes2012
-23
2/61Jonas Mouton2011
-19
Los Angeles Rams
Los Angeles Rams Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/13Aaron Donald2014
129
1/1Jared Goff2016
67
1/14Robert Quinn2011
53
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/69Cooper Kupp2017
74
2/57Rob Havenstein2015
56
2/33Rodger Saffold2010
52
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/177Puka Nacua2023
78
4/135John Franklin-Myers2018
46
5/164Kyren Williams2022
35
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/13Adam Carriker2007
-27
1/2Greg Robinson2014
-26
1/15Tye Hill2006
-21
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/46Joe Klopfenstein2006
-23
3/68Claude Wroten2006
-19
2/50Isaiah Pead2012
-18
Miami Dolphins
Miami Dolphins Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/8Ryan Tannehill2012
75
1/1Jake Long2008
73
1/6Jaylen Waddle2021
58
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/63Jarvis Landry2014
71
3/84De'Von Achane2023
59
3/72Olivier Vernon2012
57
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/163Reshad Jones2010
48
4/108Brian Hartline2009
42
5/151Andrew Van Ginkel2019
42
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/18Austin Jackson2020
-31
1/30Noah Igbinoghene2020
-29
1/16Jason Allen2006
-24
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/32Phillip Merling2008
-27
2/40John Beck2007
-26
2/42Liam Eichenberg2021
-24
Minnesota Vikings
Minnesota Vikings Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/22Justin Jefferson2020
88
1/7Adrian Peterson2007
76
1/29Harrison Smith2012
74
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/88Danielle Hunter2015
73
2/44Sidney Rice2007
57
2/41Dalvin Cook2017
55
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/146Stefon Diggs2015
85
4/100Everson Griffen2010
55
6/172Brandon Fusco2011
39
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/12Christian Ponder2011
-35
1/17Chad Greenway2006
-32
1/23Laquon Treadwell2016
-29
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/43Tyrell Johnson2008
-24
3/66Kellen Mond2021
-19
3/66Josh Robinson2012
-18
New England Patriots
New England Patriots Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/27Devin McCourty2010
77
1/21Chandler Jones2012
70
1/17Nate Solder2011
66
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/42Rob Gronkowski2010
98
3/78Joe Thuney2016
65
2/58Sebastian Vollmer2009
62
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/131Shaq Mason2015
64
4/101Trey Flowers2015
64
7/232Julian Edelman2009
60
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/24Brandon Meriweather2007
-18
1/32N'Keal Harry2019
-18
1/21Laurence Maroney2006
-13
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/36Chad Jackson2006
-24
2/40Ron Brace2009
-22
2/33Ras-I Dowling2011
-22
New Orleans Saints
New Orleans Saints Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/24Cameron Jordan2011
84
1/32Ryan Ramczyk2017
81
1/20Brandin Cooks2014
62
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/47Michael Thomas2016
89
3/75Terron Armstead2013
81
3/67Alvin Kamara2017
68
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/108Jahri Evans2006
101
5/164Carl Nicks2008
82
7/252Marques Colston2006
70
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/31Stephone Anthony2015
-27
1/7Sedrick Ellis2008
-27
1/28Payton Turner2021
-26
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/44Hau'oli Kikaha2015
-24
3/75Garrett Grayson2015
-16
3/88Johnny Patrick2011
-15
New York Giants
New York Giants Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/12Odell Beckham Jr.2014
78
1/17Dexter Lawrence2019
71
1/15Jason Pierre-Paul2010
60
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/46Linval Joseph2010
55
2/55Dalvin Tomlinson2017
52
2/36Xavier McKinney2020
52
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/153Kevin Boss2007
45
7/250Ahmad Bradshaw2007
42
5/174Devon Kennard2014
30
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/30Deandre Baker2019
-28
1/20Aaron Ross2007
-24
1/10Eli Apple2016
-20
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/50Azeez Ojulari2021
-22
2/52Marvin Austin2011
-21
2/44Sinorice Moss2006
-20
New York Jets
New York Jets Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/14Darrelle Revis2007
94
1/29Nick Mangold2006
93
1/4Sauce Gardner2022
67
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/77Demario Davis2012
54
2/47David Harris2007
48
2/39Marcus Maye2017
37
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/193Matt Slauson2009
50
4/113Dwight Lowery2008
32
5/158Brandon Shell2016
27
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/6Vernon Gholston2008
-39
1/2Zach Wilson2021
-38
1/9Dee Milliner2013
-37
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/37Devin Smith2015
-25
2/43Stephen Hill2012
-23
2/49Kellen Clemens2006
-23
Philadelphia Eagles
Philadelphia Eagles Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/12Fletcher Cox2012
83
1/13Brandon Graham2010
74
1/2Carson Wentz2016
58
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/53Jalen Hurts2020
76
2/53LeSean McCoy2009
63
2/49Dallas Goedert2018
59
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/191Jason Kelce2011
88
7/233Jordan Mailata2018
63
7/218Jordan Poyer2013
51
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/26Marcus Smith2014
-29
1/21Jalen Reagor2020
-28
1/22Andre Dillard2019
-24
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/39Winston Justice2006
-24
2/36Kevin Kolb2007
-24
2/47Trevor Laws2008
-19
Pittsburgh Steelers
Pittsburgh Steelers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/30T.J. Watt2017
91
1/31Cameron Heyward2011
79
1/24David DeCastro2012
77
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/82Emmanuel Sanders2010
66
2/48Le'Veon Bell2013
62
2/46LaMarr Woodley2007
62
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/195Antonio Brown2010
103
4/132Nick Herbig2023
59
4/131Willie Colon2006
54
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/10Devin Bush Jr.2019
-35
1/17Jarvis Jones2013
-33
1/32Evander Hood2009
-27
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/53Limas Sweed2008
-22
2/56Senquez Golson2015
-20
2/58Sean Davis2016
-17
San Francisco 49ers
San Francisco 49ers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/11Patrick Willis2007
108
1/2Nick Bosa2019
92
1/28Joe Staley2007
78
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/91NaVorro Bowman2010
79
3/70Fred Warner2018
73
3/77Chris Borland2014
72
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/146George Kittle2017
84
7/262Brock Purdy2022
66
5/142D.J. Reed2018
42
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/3Solomon Thomas2017
-41
1/14Javon Kinlaw2020
-35
1/3Trey Lance2021
-35
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/40Tank Carradine2013
-24
3/68Will Redmond2016
-19
3/70Marcus Martin2014
-18
Seattle Seahawks
Seattle Seahawks Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/14Earl Thomas2010
76
1/6Russell Okung2010
54
1/5Devon Witherspoon2023
50
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/75Russell Wilson2012
112
2/47Bobby Wagner2012
97
3/69Tyler Lockett2015
67
Day 3 Bests
Rating
5/154Richard Sherman2011
100
5/133Kam Chancellor2010
63
4/99K.J. Wright2011
55
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/4Aaron Curry2009
-39
1/29L.J. Collier2019
-28
1/27Jordyn Brooks2020
-19
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/35Malik McDowell2017
-26
2/48Darrell Taylor2020
-23
2/56D'Wayne Eskridge2021
-21
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Tampa Bay Buccaneers Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/7Mike Evans2014
85
1/13Tristan Wirfs2020
76
1/3Gerald McCoy2010
74
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/84Chris Godwin2017
71
2/58Lavonte David2012
68
2/61Ali Marpet2015
61
Day 3 Bests
Rating
6/174Keith Tandy2012
34
4/101Mike Williams2010
33
4/117Jordan Whitehead2018
20
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/5Devin White2019
-40
1/4Gaines Adams2007
-37
1/11Vernon Hargreaves III2016
-36
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/35Brian Price2010
-26
2/39Noah Spence2016
-23
2/59Roberto Aguayo2016
-20
Tennessee Titans
Tennessee Titans Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/11Taylor Lewan2014
64
1/8Jack Conklin2016
62
1/19Jeffery Simmons2019
55
Day 2 Bests
Rating
2/51A.J. Brown2019
88
2/45Derrick Henry2016
76
3/77Jurrell Casey2011
74
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/116Stephen Tulloch2006
54
6/203Jason McCourty2009
52
4/104Alterraun Verner2010
49
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/22Caleb Farley2021
-31
1/22Rashaan Evans2018
-30
1/29Isaiah Wilson2020
-27
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/33Kevin Dodd2016
-27
2/45LenDale White2006
-24
2/50Chris Henry2007
-21
Washington Commanders
Washington Commanders Best Picks
Biggest Busts
Day 1 Bests
Rating
1/5Brandon Scherff2015
59
1/17Jonathan Allen2017
49
1/26Montez Sweat2019
49
Day 2 Bests
Rating
3/76Terry McLaurin2019
61
3/85Jordan Reed2013
57
3/66Morgan Moses2014
51
Day 3 Bests
Rating
4/102Kirk Cousins2012
75
6/173Alfred Morris2012
46
6/199Chase Roullier2017
37
Day 1 Busts
ROI
1/15Dwayne Haskins2019
-32
1/19Jamin Davis2021
-24
1/22Josh Doctson2016
-20
Day 2 Busts
ROI
2/35Rocky McIntosh2006
-25
2/41Jarvis Jenkins2011
-25
2/34Devin Thomas2008
-22
